Garden Witch Life Review – An Ambitious Cozy Full of Magical Potential

It’s no secret that I’m a lover of all things witchy and cozy. Put them together and add some recipes for me to bake, and I’m sold. Garden Witch Life combines incredibly cute graphics with a unique farming system and a dash of magic.

The moment I stepped into the world of Garden Witch Life, I found myself grabbing screenshots not just because it’s my job, but because of the many truly beautiful, photo-worthy moments in the early story.

There is so much to love in Garden Witch Life, but the game is not without its flaws, especially at launch.

One quick note before we dive in – this review was written based on PC gameplay. The console release of Garden Witch Life ran into technical issues that caused an older version of the game to go out at launch. Console players may encounter more significant bugs than those reflected in my review.

Key Details

• Developer: Freetime Studio
• Publisher: SOEDESCO
• Platforms: PC (via Steam or Epic Games); Nintendo Switch; Playstation 5; Xbox Series X|S
• Price: $19.99 on PC; $29.99 on console
• Review Copy Provided: Yes
• DLC Available: No

A Deliberately Slow-Paced Story Encourages Exploration

When you first hop into Garden Witch Life, your goals are clear. They pop up in the sidebar and help you acclimate to the game – at first. Soon, however, you find yourself not entirely sure what comes next.

While this can be a bit frustrating, it also encouraged me to explore. Determined to find my next quest, I found far more hidden areas and chests than I normally would in a game with clearer objectives.

Let’s face it: I’m not typically a wanderer. But Garden Witch Life showed me adorable frogs sometimes lie on the other side of getting a little lost. (Yes, you can pet the frogs).

Although some players will still want less lag between clear quest objectives, there’s plenty to do besides tick off the quest log. It just takes figuring out what those other things are.

As much as the game encourages exploring the world, you do have some limitations early on. Garden Witch Life employs a stamina and fatigue system that can be a bit confusing to figure out. I kept passing out mid-adventure with a full stamina bar. Eventually, I realized it was because my fatigue bar was full.

I like the idea of a game being realistic with you about what a person can accomplish in a day. However, the fatigue bar does feel a bit too punishing at times.

Even just wandering around watering my crops and giving a few gifts could leave me too close to fatigue to do any exploring. In a game that wants you to find those secret nooks and crannies to open up more stories, this certainly slowed me down a bit more than I wanted.

A Creative Spin on Farming & Selling Crops

Garden Witch Life offers a unique spin on the farming genre. Here, each plant has its own energy that influences those around it. Your goal is healing the soil, which has been depleted by overproduction of a certain crop.

As a farmer’s wife, I loved this realistic look at how the health of soil impacts plants – even using compost to enrich the soil, just like my husband does at home.

The lack of clearly plowed lines freed me from my longstanding garden game shame. I can’t make neat lines of crops to save my life, and I like that Garden Witch Life encourages the chaos gardener in us all. My plants are everywhere and they like it that way.

Those with more organized intentions can build planter boxes, though I confess I enjoyed my wild sprawl too much to spend precious coins on such things.

Of course, growing the crops is only the beginning. What happens next is also a bit different in Garden Witch Life. When one of the characters first explained the sale system, I was thrilled to see a fresh approach.

There’s one way of selling crops that relies on community connection: the Community Box. It takes longer to sell your wares, but you earn more money and build up the community connection.

On the other hand, you can earn pennies by quickly selling things in the MagiBuy system (basically, the magical world version of Amazon). You get coins faster, but less of them.

As much as I wanted to love this system, I do feel it needed better balance. Even when using the more rewarding Community Box, I struggled to make enough money early on to buy the upgrades I needed. Because so many of my recipes required expensive tools to make, I couldn’t seem to make much of anything that would fetch a good price.

I’m fine with a little grind, but this felt like just a smidge too much, given how hard it was to make any recipes without some of those 1,000 coin tool blueprints.

Cooking That Really Feels Like You’re Making Something

I’m an avid home baker with a love for really digging into complicated recipes. So, I can be a bit tough on cooking mechanics when I feel they don’t let me be a part of the experience. I’m pleased to report that Garden Witch Life delivered a cooking mechanic I genuinely love.

You don’t just gather ingredients and watch them magically become a dish with the press of a button. Here, you prep each ingredient and then follow an actual recipe. The steps appear on the side of the screen and you add each ingredient, stir, heat, and cool the pot at different points.

Some players may find the extra steps a bit much. But me? I love that cooking in this game feels like following an actual recipe. I could stir my little smiling cauldron, making soups all day long.

Yes, there are a million kitchen tools that each need to be unlocked by spending money. But if my actual kitchen is any indication, that’s just kind of how it goes. Plus, I get to explore a slightly different twist of the mouse or click of a button each time I unlock a new tool and the world of possibilities it entails.

A Beautiful World That Needs a Bit More Polish

Garden Witch Life is a beautiful game. The player character is a cute little chibi witch, and the world you explore is full of lush plants and cute animals to befriend. I was enthralled when I learned that you could pet every animal.

Even better, these cute critters are attracted to your farm in part by your efforts to heal the ecosystem. I couldn’t stop smiling when I first awoke to snails roaming around my yard.

As much as I love the graphics, the game has some visual bugs at launch that occasionally pulled me out of the flow. Being the person I am, I immediately popped a witch hat onto my avatar. Unfortunately, it doesn’t play well with her hair. Her hat and part of her hair vanish when whenever the camera pans a certain way, leaving a bald little witch.

Honestly, this is mostly a funny little glitch that I’m sure will get ironed out in a future patch. However, the visual issues do sometimes impact gameplay.

For instance, you have to swim in a certain area to progress the story. Unfortunately, the camera sometimes doesn’t render properly, and your character vanishes from view. This makes it impossible to proceed since you can’t see where you’re going. Thankfully, there’s a built-in “reset player location” prompt in the menu that helped me get around that issue.

I also lost a newly crafted table to the sky because it somehow jumped up there when I was trying to place it. I can’t reach it with my hammer to move it, so it just sort of… lives up there now. Pretty minor in the scheme of things, but I did lose those crafting materials.

My other quibble with the world of Garden Witch Life is its inhabitants. Each of the NPC characters has a unique appearance and personality, which I enjoyed. However, they don’t have much in the way of dialogue options. You build relationships primarily through giving gifts, and that’s also the main way you get to know these colorful characters.

I loved how May helped me through the beginning of my story, and I wanted to chat with her every day and get to know her. Sadly, as of now, I can mostly just give her a nice flower and say goodbye until the next day. I couldn’t help but wish that a game so focused on building community connections gave me, the player, more of a look into that community.

You unlock more dialogue through special events and quests in the game, and I always look forward to these moments. But because the pacing involves a lot of days with no quest progression, these bright bits of character development take some work to uncover.

Final Score – 7.5/10

Garden Witch Life feels like a truly ambitious entry to the farming sim/cozy genre. The game aims to do things differently, creating a unique experience even for seasoned cozy gamers. Its slow pace and richly gorgeous world invite players to sink in and stay a while.

There is so much here that I am excited to see, and it’s clear that a lot of thought and care went into creating every mechanic in this game. Unfortunately, it does feel that the game came out a bit before it was fully finished, leaving some bugs and balance issues that hampered my enjoyment of this beautiful world.

With some bug fixes and patches to address balance, I think Garden Witch Life could truly become a magical gem for cozy gamers to enjoy. As it stands, however, some aspects do fall just a little bit short of their full potential.

**A Steam review code for Garden Witch Life was provided to Bonus Action for the purpose of this review**

About The Author