How to Romance Fiona in Moonlight Peaks – Gift & Heart Event Guide

Spell Practice

To start Fiona’s first heart event, find her in the forest at any time after reaching your first heart with her. You’ll catch her mid-spell and clearly not having a good time of it, snapping at the air between incantations.

Ask if everything’s okay and she’ll brush it off as a common mishap, admitting only that it’s been happening a lot “lately.” Push a little further and she opens up more: this spell used to come easily to her, and she’s not used to admitting she’s struggling, not when people look to her for answers. She’ll insist she’s got it under control and doesn’t need an audience.

Dialogue Choices:

• After watching her struggle for a bit
  • “Got it. I’ll let you focus.” (smooth, immediate warmth: “Appreciated. Distractions don’t exactly improve precision.”)
  • “Sure you don’t want help?” (a brief defensive reflex first: “I said I’ve got it… But thanks for asking.”)

Strained Expectations

After reaching two hearts with Fiona, you’ll find her practicing again, this time with Luna, Sabrina, and Noel watching. She’s losing control at the exact same point in the spell over and over, and when Luna gently tells her she doesn’t have to prove anything tonight, Fiona snaps back that she’s not supposed to have off days, not when she’s the head witch. Sabrina isn’t shy about pointing out that Fiona’s own advice, that you can’t force magic, might apply to her too.

Dialogue Choices:

• When everyone leaves and you approach her, ask
  • “You okay?” (she deflects with a joke first: “I’m fine… Just reconsidering all my life choices.”)
  • “That looked intense.” (“‘Intense’ is a polite word for it.”)

• Fiona explains she was sure she’d finally get it right this time. Respond,
  • “Maybe you should take a break.” (she resists at first: “That’s the kind of advice that sounds wise until you’re the one hearing it.”)
  • “You’ll get it eventually.” (“‘Eventually’… A comforting word, but a useless one.”)

• Fiona admits she hates feeling like she’s not measuring up to the rest of the coven. Respond,
  • “Magic is tricky.” (she almost laughs: “‘Tricky’ is one word for it. Personally, I’d go with ‘infuriating.’”)
  • “Everyone learns at their own pace.” (she deflects onto herself: “Sure. But I’m the one who’s supposed to teach that.”)

• Still frustrated, Fiona thanks you for sticking around. Respond,
  • “I’m always here to listen.“
  • “No worries.” (guarded, but softening: “You’re too kind… A dangerous trait, that.”)

Breathing Room

Fiona’s third heart event picks up after a dozen failed attempts, with Luna and Sabrina hyping her up for one more try. This time the spell actually works, and Noel, of all people, admits it was impressive. Luna insists on marking the occasion with a flower tucked into Fiona’s hair, which Fiona protests just long enough to make clear she doesn’t really mean it.

Dialogue Choices:

• When Luna and Sabrina both insist the flower suits her, back them up:
  • “It looks great on you, Fiona.” (she gives in: “You’re all conspiring against me, clearly… Fine. The flower stays, for now.” She admits she wasn’t sure she’d get through this without something going wrong, and that she needed to prove it to herself more than to anyone else.)
  • “I think Luna’s onto something.”

• Once she’s had a moment to take the win in, respond,
  • “I never doubted you for a second!” (“You have too much faith in me. But thank you, {Player}. That’s… kind of you to say.”)
  • “We all believe in you, Fiona.”

Herb Gathering

Once you’re dating, you’ll find Fiona out gathering herbs alone in her usual corner of the forest. Noel was supposed to help, she explains, but he got distracted, as usual. She admits she’s gotten used to finishing things by herself, and could use a second pair of hands if you’re offering.

Dialogue Choices:

• Offer to help,
  • “I’d love to help.” (“Thanks, darling… I’ve gotten used to finishing things alone. But I guess I don’t have to, not when you’re here.”)
  • “What are we gathering?” (same warm admission follows either way, just with the shopping list first (five purple lavender, one nightshade).)

Callous Causeway

You’ll find Fiona having dozed off mid-sentence, startling awake when you get close. She admits she fell asleep without meaning to, and that what woke her was a nightmare, an endless, crumbling stone bridge she couldn’t stop walking across, with no idea what she was even walking toward. It’s a rare crack in her usual composure: she’s the one who’s supposed to have the answers, and in the dream, she had none.

Dialogue Choices:

• Ask what she thinks the dream means,
  • “What do you think it means?” (“I don’t usually talk about things like this… But in that dream, I couldn’t fix anything. I felt… powerless.”)
  • “It must’ve really unsettled you.” (same admission follows either way.)

• Once she’s told you the whole thing, respond,
  • “You don’t have to carry that alone.” (“I know. I suppose I forget that sometimes. Thanks for waking me up. For being here.”)
  • “I’m really glad you told me.” (same thanks follows either way.)

• As the moment settles, tell her,
  • “I’ll always be here when you need me.” (“That’s… something I never thought I’d hear. Let alone believe.” She asks if you’ll stay a while, even if she falls back asleep.)
  • “You’re not alone, Fiona. Not with me around.”

A Circle Still Holds

Not long after the wedding, Fiona’s coven, Luna, Sabrina, and Noel, show up under the thin pretense of checking on married life (really, they just miss her). She’s nervier hosting than you’d expect from someone usually this composed, threatening to hex Noel’s shoelaces together over muddy floors and fussing over a homemade stew.

Dialogue Choices:

• When she gets flustered over the visit, tease her a little:
  • “You’re kind of adorable when you’re fussing.” (“Am I now? Well… Maybe I care more than I like to admit.”)
  • “You nervous?” (“Maybe a little.”)

• After everyone leaves and the two of you are alone, Fiona admits she used to think she didn’t need anyone, until she found people who proved her wrong. Respond,
  • “You’ve changed me too, you know.” (“Have I? Then I suppose we’re even.”)
  • “I’m glad they got to see this side of you.” (“I’m glad I got to share it with those closest to me.”)

Bite Me, Pretty Please (and Can You Bite Me?)

This one plays out over two conversations. Fiona works up to something she’s clearly been sitting with for a while: she wants to become a vampire, like you. She’s careful to frame it as something she’s actually thought through, not a whim, pointing out she’s not planning to be head witch forever anyway since Sabrina will eventually take over.

Dialogue Choices:

• When she finally asks outright,
  • “I would love to turn you!” (“Really? That’s… wonderful to hear.” She’ll ask you to meet her at the crypt on the plot.)
  • “I’m not sure that’s a good idea.” (she takes it in stride: “I see. I’ll ask again to see if you’ve changed your mind.”)

• On the second visit, she checks in again: “So, have you been thinking about it?” Respond,
  • “I did.” (“Oh, really? So, are you going to make me wait forever, or are you ready to make me a vampire? …I want to be with you forever.”)
  • “You’re gonna have to be more specific.”